Burning Questions | Margaret Atwood #CANessays

Burning Questions is my third collection of essays and other occasional pieces. The first Second Words, which began in 1960, when I started publishing book reviews, and ended in 1982. The second was Moving Targets, which gathered materials from 1983 to mid-2004. Burning Questions runs from mid-2004 to mid-2021. So, twenty years, give or take, for each volume.

After reading Liz @Adventures in Reading‘s review of Burning Questions earlier this year, and the various comments she made about it on her blog and on mine, I determined to take my time reading these essays. Liz enjoyed the essays a lot but felt she had rushed them instead of savouring each one properly.

It may be giving you more information than you ever need to know about me, but Burning Questions became my bathroom book. The shortish length of most of the essays meant that each one could be read in one (ahem) sitting, so to speak.

In case you were wondering, I have books stashed all around the house and in various bags so that I am never without the option to read. The pile of half-read books by my bed is ridiculous and not worth mentioning here, but I also have two books on the coffee table (one non-fiction and one children’s book), one non-fiction book in my walking backpack and another in my work backpack. Another fiction title is being slowly read at work during my lunch breaks and a non-fiction book sits next to my home laptop. The calico bag that I take up to the mountains every time we go also has a non-fiction book tucked inside, just in case!

This is why it takes me such a long time to finish non-fiction books. I not only have more than one book on the go at once, but they are room specific as well. Burning Questions took me eight months to read this way. I certainly savoured every single essay!

One advantage of reading this way is that it gave certain essays time to influence my other books.

Burning Questions had a number of wonderful such connections, from the nature of writing and translation, women’s issues, climate change and the recognition that we all get older eventually. Atwood and I also share a fascination with Ryszard Kapuściński, Alice Munro, Anne of Green Gables, Charles Dickens, Hilary Mantel, Rachel Carson, Stephen King, Shakespeare, Ray Bradbury, Anna Akhmatova, Simone de Beauvoir and poetry.

Atwood uses her introduction to explain how she divided up the book and the things that were concerning her most at the time (the aftermath of 9/11, the Obama years, climate change, her partner Graeme Gibson’s dementia diagnosis, the Trump years and, of course, the pandemic).

I am not going to discuss every single essay – that would be tedious for all of us concerned! But I will highlight some favourites.

Scientific Romancing: for instance did you know that the French have two words for short stories – contes and nouvelles – ‘tales’ and ‘news’ or perhaps ‘daily life’. This struck me as important in a way I hope/plan to tease out more as I reread and rediscover William Trevor’s short stories in the coming year with Cathy & Kim. In this essay, Atwood went on to define science fiction proper as “things we can’t yet do or begin to do, like going through a wormhole”. For her the science part is about knowledge while the fiction is about our desires and/or fears.

She obviously has a thing about this, as it comes up regularly in her essays and talks.

She prefers to call her writing speculative fiction with its focus on “the consequences of new & proposed technologies” and “changes in social organistaions” i.e. utopias and dystopias. For anyone who has read anything about Atwood’s thinking or writing processes with The Handmaid’s Tale you will already know that everything that happened in the story, was drawn from real events in history, or was a logical/possible extension of something that had already happend to women somewhere in the world at some point in history. She wasn’t making stuff up, she was simply combining it into one futuristic story, a story about the possible consequences of following a certain politico-religious line of thinking.

Polonia: made me laugh out loud when Atwood commented on the wisdom of giving advice to the young. “Hands up, everyone who’s ever taped laundry instructions to the washer-dryer for the benefit of their teenage children.” I taped ours on so well, it is still there! B22 though, continues to blatantly ignore the bit about how much powder is actually required for each load based on the slowly growing layer of powder detritus in the drawer. He believes that more is better. It may also have something to do with not having to cover the cost of replacement powder….yet!

Wetlands: 2006

Everyone would much rather be told that things are fine, the world is safe, we’re all nice people, and nothing is anyone’s fault – above all, that we can keep on doing exactly whatever we like, without taking any thought or changing our so-called lifestyle in the least, and there will be no bad consequences.

Literature and the Environment is her essay on climate change and the role of writers to represent these topics in their books, from her 2010 PEN Congress, Tokyo speech. Her comments fueled my enjoyment of Haven by Emma Donoghue.

Bring Up the Bodies 2012: Having reread the Hilary Mantel trilogy only last year, this essay was informative. But Atwood also nailed what it is that I love about historical fiction. It’s not about the timeline, dates and places. It’s about the people and how they lived through such times, not knowing what was coming next. Good historical fiction takes us there.

We read historical fiction for the same reason we keep watching Hamlet: it’s not what, it’s how. And although we know the plot, the characters themselves do not.

There were various pieces on writing the MaddAddam trilogy which made me realise that, yes, I do want to finish this trilogy after all. I read Oryx and Crake about ten years ago. I enjoyed it but not excessively so, therefore I didn’t bother when the next two were published. Atwood describes Oryx and Crake as “an adventure-romance coupled with a Menippean satire.” What? Normally she explains such things, but for some reason she left Menippean hanging out there.

A duck, duck, go revealed that it is a form of prose satire named after the Greek cynic, Menippus (3rd century BCE) that is ‘characterized by attacking mental attitudes instead of specific individuals‘ (thank you yourdictionary).

A number of her essays refer to her love of early science fiction writers. I now want to read more Ray Bradbury stories thanks to Atwood and We by Yevgeny Zamyatin.

The essay about being the first author selected for The Future Library prompted me to check out my 2020 post on the Library. I have now updated the authors to 2022 and wordpress-ised the formating.

Shakespeare & Me 2016: I totally agree with the comment below, but also would add that some book characters are not easy to spend time with. Their unlikeable, objectionable traits can make it difficult for a reader to continue unless the writing, or plotting, or topic make up for this somehow.

People who object to works of literature because the characters in them are not people you would want to marry or have for a room-mate have entirely missed the point.

Oryx and Crake 2018: The above and this quote is something I’ve tried to keep in mind as I’ve been reading Voss this month. Voss may not be likeable and Laura may the only person who would ever want to ever marry him, but Patrick White’s writing is stunning. What questions PW was asking though, is something I’m still grappling with.

Novels don’t provide answers…novels ask questions.

Growing Up in Quarantineland 2020: Atwood lists six ways of dealing with difficult times. I like to think I put into action 1,3,5 and 6 during the pandemic, although Mr Books and I may have consumed quite a bit of cheese and wine between March 2020 – January 2022, suggesting a little bit on number 2 was in play.

  1. Protect yourself.
  2. Give up and party…
  3. Help others.
  4. Blame.
  5. Bear witness (my Covid Chronicles series)
  6. Go about your life.

Also this friendly reminder, that it is not over yet. The end, the After, is not here yet. We may not be in the middle of the pandemic any longer, these may be the dying days of it that we are currently living through. But it is still a part of our lives. The variants are changing almost monthly. People are still catching Covid and getting sick, and some people are still so sick from it that they end up in hospital and some of those are dying. We may live with the social, economic and political ramifications of this time for many more years to come. I wonder how history will judge us?

We just need to make it through this part, between Before and After. As novelists know, the middle section is the hardest part to figure out.

I found most of these essays fascinating, interesting, engaging and/or amusing. For such a large collection that is quite an achievement! Highly recommended for Atwood fans.

Favourite Quotes: Two comments struck me anew as I was thumbing through the book for this post. History and what we can learn from it is obviously an obsession that both Atwood and I will take with us to our graves!

History is simply human beings doing stuff….History isn’t what happened – it’s the stories we tell about what happened. How we interpret and present what happened….the past as we know it is always changing.

I write books about possible unpleasant futures in the hope that we will not allow these futures into reality.

Title: Burning Questions: Essays and Occasional Pieces 2004-2021
Author: Maraget Atwood
ISBN: 9781784744519
Imprint: Chatto & Windus
Published: 1 March 2022
Format: Hardback
Pages: 496
Dates Read: 29th March 2022 - 21 November 2022
  • This post was written on the traditional land of the Wangal clan, one of the 29 clans of the Eora Nation within the Sydney basin. This Reading Life acknowledges that Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples are this land’s first storytellers.

29 thoughts on “Burning Questions | Margaret Atwood #CANessays

  1. I also have numerous books on-the-go at all times and stashed in various places. This essay collection was my at-the-office-lunchtime book for a chunk of the year. I found it interesting and thought-provoking. The history quote jumped out at me as well. I would encourage you to read the rest of the MaddAdam trilogy. It was SO good!

    Like

  2. I hang my head in shame…never read anything by Ms Atwood. I know, I should but the Handmaid’s Tale sounds so depressing…tell me I should read it. Perhaps I can ease into MA writing with these essays. Thanks for bring them to my attention. 🙂

    Like

    1. Given your preference for non-fiction, Atwood’s essays would be a good place to start, although quite a few of the ones in this collection reference her novels, adding to my enjoyment of them.

      Like

    1. Here’s a list of some of our nonfiction bestsellers at work this year:

      Not Now, Not Ever by Julia Gillard
      Wandering With Intent | Kim Mahood
      The Book of Roads and Kingdoms | Richard Fidler
      The Ninth LIfe of Diamond Miner | Grace Tame
      My Dream Time | Ash Barty
      Cressida Campbell | National Gallery of Australia
      Dreamers and Schmeres | Frank Bongiorno
      Making Australian History | Anna Clark
      We Come With This Place | Debra Dank
      Chasing Wromgs and Rights | Elaine Pearson
      Black Lives White Law | Russell Marks
      August in Kabul | Andrew Quilty
      Sneaky Little Revolutions | Charmaine Clift
      The First Astronomers | Duane Hamacher
      The Idea of Australia | Julianne Schultz
      Mission | Noel Pearson
      Signs and Wonders | Delia Falconer
      Under Her Skin | Sue Williams
      Raised by Wolves | Jess Ho
      Enclave | Claire G Coleman
      Indelible City | Louisa Lim
      The Avoidable War | Kevin Rudd
      Another Day in the Colony | Chelsea Watego
      Truth-Telling | Henry Reynolds

      Most of the Quarterly Essays this year (I’m looking forward to the one On Albanese due out later this week)

      Poetry – Art | Charmaine Papertalk Green and John Kinsella
      Hope this helps Nancy 🙂

      Like

  3. Your review has whet my appetite for my own copy of Burning Questions. I haven’t even cracked the spine yet, although I thought I would by now. Soon, I hope!
    P.S. Poetry collections make good bathroom books as well. 🙂

    Like

  4. I loved Polonia, too. Thank you for the shout-out and I can see you got more out of it reading it over ages rather than hurrying through it – I also didn’t know how long it was, reading the e-book, which didn’t help!

    Like

    1. Most of the essays can be read quite quickly. That helps with such a chunky book!
      I found it interesting to see the templates that MA used to create speeches versus introductions to books. Almost like seeing into her private writing processes.

      Like

  5. As someone who has yet to acquire a copy of this collection, I’m doubly appreciative of the attention you’ve drawn to individual pieces herein (I remember Liz’s post was great too–I can see how she would have inspired you to make time for this collection). The writers/works that you’ve earmarked as sharing with with MA are some of the connections I’ve found too (AoGG being an early one!) but it also sounds like we both enjoy what we do NOT have in common with her, when she turns her gaze to it, as what we do. Both the quotations you’ve selected are excellent choices, reflecting so much of her work, both on and off the page: when you read them, you can glimpse so much of what she’s all about.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Thank you replying under a different account. For some reason I cannot reply to your comments from the BIP account. There are also times when I cannot access your blog full stop.

      I think you will love this collection. It is very Atwoodian!

      I hope you are staying warm & cosy.

      Like

      1. Atwoodian should be in the dictionary! My comment is from my BIP account, I just changed the way my name displays (I’ve long had privacy concerns but have recently set some of them aside)…and this makes it easier for you to reply?
        Whispering Gums has a hard time connecting to leave comments on BIP sometimes, too, but I think her site is WP and it looks like yours is not? But maybe WP still hosts for you even though you have your own URL? Mine uses WP to manage the content but it’s hosted elsewhere and I’m convinced WP holds a grudge against that choice. Heheh It’s so frustrating when I know that something technical is interfering with conversations because that’s the only reason I’m online, to talk about books and writing! I’ll try to fix it if I can.

        Like

        1. I thought so originally, then realised I can reply to comments you leave in my blog easily. But getting into your blog is very sporadic indeed. It usually comes up with a security alert message. That would be very mean of WP – I would have thought that lots of business accounts in particular have their hosting elsewhere.

          Like

          1. Ahhh, yes, that’s to do with your firewall/security settings. My site has a prefix of https because it’s not a commercial site, so I don’t have the security layer that http sites have, which would usher it through your firewall. WordPress includes that layer for free for its clients (probably because they collect extra-juicy data from commercial accounts that are happy to have it, for “free”); but, with other hosting sites, it’s an add-on which is very costly (as most “business-type” services are, and business-owners can use the expense as a deductible, but as I’m not a business I would rather buy…books!). You might find, now, that as you revisit which sites you have difficulty accessing, that little letter ‘s’ might explain it for you. There are a lot of them–including one of my regular libraries!–but you don’t really notice it until it gets in your way. Sorry if this is too much information, certainly it’s a long comment!

            Liked by 1 person

            1. Thanks for the info Marcie. It made me check too. I remember looking into it when my blog went from http to https, so it was good to have a recap!

              I tried to leave a comment on your blog as I thought I had tricked it by opening your blog via the Feedly app, but it seems to have disappeared anyway 🤷🏼‍♀️

              Like

  6. Pingback: 2022 | The Books

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s