A quotation from Blaise Pascal acts as epigraph for the story,
We never keep to the present. We recall the past; we anticipate the future as if we found it too slow in coming and were trying to hurry it up, or we recall the past as if to stay its too rapid flight. We are so unwise that we wander about in times that do not belong to us…
Philip and Nina’s history is told over the course of one night.
It’s the night that Philip has died in his sleep after having a little lie down after work and just before dinner. Nina sits, shocked, with Philip’s body, and throughout the long night, she remembers some of the moments that made their marriage what it was – their first meeting in Paris, the birth of their daughter, Philip’s career as a mathematician, the flirtations, arguments and counselling, the jealousy, the secrets and, of course, their love, that endured it all.
Philip was a mathematician, so quite a lot of probability and philosophy was thrown into the mix. His rational nature often clashed with Nina’s more artistic soul and their marriage, like most, I guess, became a compromise and dance around each other’s emotional abilities and needs.
This is where Tuck excelled. She showed us the complicated and sometimes random nature of grief. Weird trivial thoughts and practical matters often interrupted and intruded on Nina’s ability to process what had happened. The reality of her loss would hit her anew, as another memory led her back to this present moment. And then off again.
Tuck used a fragmentary style of writing which suited the in and out, to and fro nature of Nina’s thoughts. The writing was sparse yet delicate as Tuck explored the age-old tragedy of how one partner will eventually predecease the other in any marriage. And that even though we all know this harsh fact right from the start, it still catches us by surprise when it actually happens.
|Rest on the Flight into Egypt, Caravaggio|
The only really weird moment for me, the reader, was the ending. Was it all a dream? Or did Nina create a fantasy to sustain herself in her grief? Given that her favourite painting was Caravaggio’s Rest on the Flight into Egypt, the reference to an angel with black wings is perhaps not so surprising, and could be seen as a sign of comfort and solace seeking in her time of need.
Seeking comfort is one of the essential strategies we all need to develop to distract ourselves from our grief. We will never erase or forget our emotional memories, and closure is a myth, but we can plan for and soothe ourselves when those intense emotions and memories are triggered.
Perhaps that’s what Tuck was trying to tell us all along – that we all have the ability to comfort ourselves when the time comes.
If you enjoyed Kent Haruf’s Our Souls At Night, Tinkers by Paul Harding or Chesil Beach by Ian McEwan you might also enjoy this.
4 thoughts on “I Married You For Happiness by Lily Tuck”
I just finished and liked Our Souls at Night, so I'd better add this book to my list, but first I need to read The Tinkers as it is on my nightstand.
Interesting what you say about the themes of death and sorrow that seem to be prevalent. That's why I mostly avoid modern fiction, not necessarily because of those themes but the bleakness and helplessness around them. The classics have the same themes but often there is some sort of hope and redemption attached to them, or at least some sort of life lesson. In any case, I really enjoyed your review! 🙂
I read Tinkers about 5-6 yrs ago and it still haunts me – I'd love to reread it one day to see if affects me the same way.
It was only when I had time to sit down to write this book response that I realised/thought through that Tuck did give us a hopeful life lesson at the end of this book. Until then, the book's ending was leaving me feeling a little 'meh'.